The average Texas homeowners premium was $3,489 in 2025, according to the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI), up from $2,124 four years earlier. You cannot change hail or building costs, but several parts of the bill are in your hands. Here they are, with the trade-off each one carries.

1. Compare companies, on the same terms

Prices for the same house differ from one insurer to the next. TDI's advice is to use HelpInsure.com, which it runs with the Office of Public Insurance Counsel, to see sample prices and compare policies, then contact your top choices for quotes. Make every quote use the same dwelling coverage, the same deductibles and the same roof settlement, or the cheapest one may simply be the one that covers least.

2. Check the company, not just the price

A low premium from a company that fights claims is not a saving. Look at each finalist's complaint index and rate filings. A company that has filed large increases two years running may not stay cheap.

3. Ask about every discount

TDI says most companies offer discounts and that they vary by company. The ones it lists:

  • a monitored burglar or fire alarm;
  • a fire sprinkler system;
  • an impact-resistant roof;
  • other policies with the same company, such as auto; and
  • no claims for three years in a row.

Ask which ones you qualify for, and ask for the list in writing.

4. Raise the deductible, carefully

TDI's rule of thumb is that the higher the deductible, the lower the premium, and it gives a figure: going from a $500 deductible to $1,000 can save as much as 20%. The cost is real, though. A deductible applies to every claim, and a percentage deductible on a $400,000 house runs to thousands of dollars. Only raise it to an amount you could pay tomorrow. Our deductible guide shows the math.

5. Do not file claims you can absorb

TDI warns that filing small claims may affect what you pay later. Texas law lets an insurer add a surcharge once you have filed two or more non-weather claims in three years, and refuse to renew after three. A claim-free record is also one of the discounts TDI lists. Use insurance for losses you could not cover yourself.

6. Ask for a credit exception if you qualify

Many insurers use credit information in pricing. If your credit was damaged by a serious illness or injury, the death of a spouse, child or parent, temporary job loss, divorce or identity theft, you can ask in writing for an exception, and the insurer must then set those events aside or use a neutral score. See our credit guide.

7. Insure for rebuilding cost, not sale price

TDI's guidance is to carry enough coverage to replace the house and your belongings if they were destroyed. That is the cost to rebuild, which is not the same as the market price and does not include the land. Ask how the insurer calculated your dwelling amount and correct anything wrong about the house, such as its size or finishes. Do not cut coverage below rebuilding cost to save premium; that is the saving people regret.

8. Shop before renewal, and never leave a gap

Start two months before the policy expires. And follow TDI's rule: never cancel a policy until you have the new one, or a written statement of coverage, in hand.

What will not work

Dropping wind and hail coverage inland, or going without insurance, saves the most and risks the house. Mortgage lenders generally require coverage in any case. The aim is a lower price for the same protection.

Sources

Related guides