Price tells you what an insurer charges. It does not tell you what happens when you file a claim. The closest thing Texas has to a public report card on that is the complaint index published by the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI). It is useful, and it is easy to misread.
What it measures
When a policyholder complains to TDI about an insurer, TDI reviews the complaint. Each year TDI publishes, for every company, the number of complaints it confirmed and the number of policies the company had in force. From those it works out the complaint index:
the company's share of all confirmed complaints, divided by the company's share of all policies.
The average is 1.00. TDI's own description is that a number below 1 means fewer complaints than average and a number above 1 means more.
A worked example
Suppose a company has 10% of the policies in Texas. If it also drew 10% of the confirmed complaints, its index is 1.00. If it drew 15% of the complaints, its index is 1.50: half again as many as its size would predict. If it drew 5%, its index is 0.50.
The point of dividing by policies is fairness. The largest insurer in the state will always have the most complaints in raw numbers. The index asks whether it has more than its share.
Five ways the index can mislead
- The "Homeowners" line is not only homeowners. TDI groups homeowners, renters, condo, dwelling and farm policies into one line. For 2025 that line held about 9.1 million policies and 1,153 confirmed complaints. A company that sells mostly renters insurance is compared on the same scale as one that insures houses, although a renters policy is far less likely to produce a disputed roof claim.
- Small companies swing wildly. With about one confirmed complaint for every 8,000 policies statewide, a company with 8,000 policies and one complaint sits at about average. A second complaint doubles its index. For small companies, look at the complaint count, not just the index.
- One year is a snapshot. Indexes move. In TDI's data several large insurers changed by half a point or more between 2024 and 2025. A storm year in one region can do that. Compare at least two years, which is why our insurer pages show both.
- Brands are split across companies. A national brand may write Texas policies through four or five legal companies, each with its own index. The name that matters is the one printed on your policy.
- Only confirmed complaints count, and only complaints made to TDI. Unhappy customers who never write to the department are invisible. The index is a floor on dissatisfaction, not a measure of it.
How to use it when shopping
- Start with price quotes, then check the index for each company still on your list.
- Find the exact legal company on the quote. Ask the agent if it is not shown.
- Treat an index well above 1.00 in two years running as a reason to ask questions, and an index near or below 1.00 as reassurance, not a guarantee.
- Check financial strength separately; the complaint index says nothing about a company's ability to pay after a catastrophe.
Our insurer pages list TDI's figures for every company with at least 1,000 policies.
Filing a complaint yourself
If your insurer has not followed its policy or the law, you can complain to TDI. Complaints must be in writing and can be filed through TDI's online complaint portal. TDI's help line is 800-252-3439. It helps to try the company first and keep copies of what you sent and when: Texas law sets deadlines for an insurer to acknowledge a claim, decide it and pay it, and dates are what a complaint turns on.
Sources
- Texas Department of Insurance: Complaint indexes and policy counts for insurance companies (dataset)
- TDI: Company complaint data
- TDI: Get help with an insurance complaint
- TDI: Home insurance guide