At the end of 2025, the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) counted 431,743 residential property policies in force with the 9 Liberty Mutual companies listed below. That is 4.76% of all policies in TDI’s Homeowners line, which includes renters, condo and dwelling policies as well as homeowners policies, and ranks Liberty Mutual number 5 among the insurers we track.

TDI confirmed 93 complaints against them in 2025. That gives a complaint index of 1.69, above the average of 1.00. That means more confirmed complaints than the share of policies would predict. TDI publishes an index for each legal company. The combined figure is our calculation, applying TDI’s formula to the companies’ added-up complaints and policies.

In 2024 the index was 0.97, on 39 confirmed complaints and 494,962 policies. A swing that large between two years is a reminder that one year’s index is a snapshot.

Measured by premium instead of policy count, TDI’s 2024 market report puts the Liberty Mutual group at 6.05% of Texas homeowners premium.

1.69
Complaint index, 2025
93
Confirmed complaints, 2025
431,743
Policies in force, 2025
4.76%
Share of policies

The companies behind the Liberty Mutual name

Complaints and rate filings are recorded against the legal company that issued the policy. Check the company name on your declarations page to see which row is yours.

Company (name on the policy)NAICPolicies in force, 2025Confirmed complaints, 2025Complaint index, 2025Policies in force, 2024Confirmed complaints, 2024Complaint index, 2024
American Economy Insurance Company19690140,112422.36148,145131.09
Safeco Insurance Company of Indiana11215138,791241.36150,66830.25
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company2304352,92400.0059,67630.62
Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company1248447,655203.3065,730163.01
Safeco Insurance Company of America2474028,07600.0035,98200.00
Liberty Insurance Corporation4240420,24762.3329,70531.25
Liberty Lloyds of Texas Insurance Company110411,87900.002,42715.10
Safeco Lloyds Insurance Company110701,35800.001,67600.00
Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company23035701111.2295300.00

Source: Texas Department of Insurance, Complaint indexes and policy counts for insurance companies. Data and methods.

Liberty Mutual rate filings in Texas

Texas insurers must file their home insurance rates with TDI before using them, and TDI reviews the filings for compliance with state law. TDI’s records show 109 homeowners or dwelling rate filings from Liberty Mutual companies received since 2021. The largest overall increase among them was +27.5%, in a filing received September 25, 2023 for Homeowners.

The percentage is the insurer’s estimate of the overall effect on its existing policyholders. Your own change can be higher or lower. A blank or 0% means the filing changed rules or something else that does not move premiums overall.

Received by TDICompany (name on the policy)ProductOverall rate changeEffective, new policiesEffective, renewalsStatusSERFF ID
2026-06-25Liberty Mutual Insurance CompanyHomeowners-0.2%2026-09-192026-10-24PendingLBPM-134993058
2026-06-04Liberty Insurance CorporationHomeowners+1.8%—2026-08-30ReviewedLBPM-134968720
2026-06-04Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance CompanyHomeowners+1.8%—2026-08-30ReviewedLBPM-134968726
2026-05-20Safeco Insurance Company of IndianaHomeowners+1.7%—2026-09-12ReviewedLBPM-134955492
2026-05-20Safeco Lloyds Insurance CompanyHomeowners+1.7%—2026-09-12ReviewedLBPM-134955492
2026-05-18American Economy Insurance CompanyHomeowners+1.7%2026-07-072026-09-12ReviewedLBPM-134946965
2026-05-18Safeco Insurance Company of IndianaHomeowners+1.7%—2026-09-12WithdrawnLBPM-134948567
2026-05-18Liberty Lloyds of Texas Insurance CompanyHomeowners+1.7%—2026-09-12WithdrawnLBPM-134948567
2026-02-12Liberty Mutual Insurance CompanyHomeowners0.0%2026-08-172026-09-21ReviewedLBPM-134834052
2025-12-05Safeco Insurance Company of IndianaRenters0.0%2026-02-212026-04-29ReviewedLBPM-134759577
2025-12-01Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance CompanyHomeowners0.0%2025-12-172026-01-21ReviewedLBPM-134754645
2025-12-01Liberty Mutual Insurance CompanyHomeowners0.0%2025-12-172026-01-21ReviewedLBPM-134754645
2025-12-01Liberty Insurance CorporationHomeowners0.0%2025-12-172026-01-21ReviewedLBPM-134754645
2025-12-01Liberty Lloyds of Texas Insurance CompanyHomeowners0.0%2025-12-172026-01-21ReviewedLBPM-134754645
2025-12-01Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance CompanyHomeowners0.0%2025-12-172026-01-21ReviewedLBPM-134754645
2025-11-26Safeco Lloyds Insurance CompanyDwelling Fire0.0%2026-02-212026-04-29ReviewedLBPM-134744183
2025-11-24American Economy Insurance CompanyHomeowners0.0%2025-12-182026-02-23ReviewedLBPM-134748760
2025-11-24American Economy Insurance CompanyHomeowners0.0%2026-02-212026-04-29ReviewedLBPM-134750287
2025-11-24Safeco Insurance Company of IndianaHomeowners0.0%2026-02-212026-04-29ReviewedLBPM-134750287
2025-11-24Safeco Lloyds Insurance CompanyHomeowners0.0%2026-02-212026-04-29ReviewedLBPM-134750287

Showing the 20 most recent of 109 filings.

Source: Texas Department of Insurance, Home and auto rate filings. Search every filing, with documents, in TDI’s rate filing data.

How to use this page

  • Compare like with like. A complaint index only means something next to other insurers’. The full list shows every company.
  • Complaints are not claims. TDI counts complaints it confirmed, about any part of the service: claims, billing, cancellations. A low index does not promise a smooth claim.
  • Check financial strength separately. We do not publish financial ratings because the rating agencies own them and change them. Ask the agent or look up the company at a rating agency such as AM Best.
  • Nothing here is a recommendation. We do not rank insurers as good or bad, and we are not paid by any of them.

Visit insurer site

Informational link to the insurer’s official site. We do not quote or bind policies and are not paid for this link.

Related guides

Other insurers