The Texas Department of Insurance counted 39,366 homeowners policies in force on March 31, 2026 in the 2 ZIP codes that cover New Braunfels. From April through July 2026, insurers reported 165 non-renewals of owner-occupied homeowners policies there. That is about 4.2 for every 1,000 policies, lower than the statewide figure of 7.2.

Over the same months insurers reported 3,171 cancellations and 1,605 declined applications in the same area. Cancellations sound alarming but mostly are not: statewide, 65% of cancellation notices said the policyholder asked for it and 34% cited a missed payment.

39,366
Homeowners policies in force
165
Non-renewals, April–July 2026
4.2
Non-renewals per 1,000 policies
7.2
Texas statewide rate

New Braunfels by ZIP code

Policies in force on March 31, 2026; notices are for owner-occupied homeowners policies, from April through July 2026.

ZIP codeHomeowners policiesNon-renewalsNon-renewals per 1,000 policiesCancellationsDeclined applicationsRenters policies
7813024,6731164.71,89467711,421
7813214,693493.31,2779282,426

ZIP codes are mail routes and do not follow city limits. We list a ZIP code under New Braunfels when the Census Bureau shows a meaningful share of it inside the city, so some homes counted here are outside the city limits and a few ZIP codes also appear under a neighboring city.

Sources: Texas Department of Insurance, Residential and Farm Policies in Force by ZIP Code; 89R HB 2067 – actual number of residential property declinations, cancellations, and nonrenewals. Data and methods.

Month by month

MonthNon-renewalsCancellationsDeclined applications
April 202647740423
May 202642759465
June 202635873369
July 202641799348

Why insurers did not renew or declined homes in New Braunfels

A notice can list more than one reason, so the shares can add up to more than 100%. Owner-occupied homeowners policies only.

Reasons for non-renewals

Reason givenNoticesShare of notices
Other action by the insurer7242%
Condition of the property: other2917%
Condition of the property: roof179.8%
Insurer withdrawing from the market169.2%
Increase in hazard137.5%
Condition of the property: maintenance, occupancy or vacancy126.9%

21% of these notices relied on aerial imagery and 23% on other third-party information, as reported by insurers.

Reasons for declined applications

Reason givenNoticesShare of notices
Exposure to loss: wildfire38532%
Location of the property26622%
Claims history22419%
Other action by the insurer19116%
Value of the home1089.0%
Condition of the property: other836.9%

53% of these notices relied on aerial imagery and 63% on other third-party information, as reported by insurers.

Source: Texas Department of Insurance, 89R HB 2067 – reasons for residential property declinations, cancellations, and nonrenewals. Data and methods.

Comal County in context

Comal County as a whole had 66,787 homeowners policies, 7,319 dwelling policies (typically rental houses) and 16,496 renters policies in force on March 31, 2026. Using ZIP codes assigned to the county, insurers reported about 178 non-renewals from April through July 2026, or roughly 2.7 per 1,000 homeowners policies.

Comal County is not one of the 14 first tier coastal counties, so wind and hail coverage here normally comes with the regular home policy, not from the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association.

Sources: Texas Department of Insurance, Residential and Farm Policies in Force by County; Texas Insurance Code § 2210.003(4). Data and methods.

What does home insurance cost in New Braunfels?

TDI does not publish an average premium for New Braunfels, and we will not guess one. The statewide average homeowners premium was $3,489 in 2025 (preliminary), for an average of $432,800 in home coverage. TDI’s homeowners market overview has a map of average premiums by county. For prices on your own home, compare quotes from several companies; HelpInsure.com, run by TDI and the Office of Public Insurance Counsel, lists sample rates by company.

If your insurer will not renew you

  • Check the notice date. Texas law requires written notice of non-renewal at least 60 days before the policy expires. Without it, the insurer must renew at your request.
  • Read the reason. Since 2026 the insurer has to put the reason in writing. If it is something you can fix, such as roof condition, ask whether repairs would change the decision.
  • Start shopping at once. Each company weighs the same house differently. Our insurer pages show each company’s complaint record and rate filings.
  • Know the fallback. If at least two companies turn you down, the Texas FAIR Plan Association sells basic coverage through agents. See how the FAIR Plan works.
  • Complain if the rules were not followed. TDI takes written complaints through its online portal and answers questions at 800-252-3439.

What these numbers can and cannot tell you

  • The rate is our arithmetic, not TDI’s. Non-renewal counts and policy counts come from two separate TDI collections. We divide one by the other so places can be compared. Treat the result as approximate.
  • The record is short. Reporting started in 2026, and the published data covers from April through July 2026. A few months cannot show a trend, and storm seasons differ by region.
  • ZIP codes are not city limits. A ZIP code’s numbers can include homes outside the city it is listed under.
  • No insurer is named. The law tells TDI to publish totals that do not identify any company, so this data cannot tell you which insurer is leaving an area.
  • A high rate is not a prediction for your home. Insurers decide policy by policy, based on the roof, claims history and their own exposure in the area.

Related guides

Other Texas cities